Showing posts with label INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 23, 2016

ANG vs. TEODORO (1942) (Ang Tibay Case)


"Talent alone cannot make a writer.  There must be a man behind the book"  
                                                 -Ralph Waldo Emerson

Mr. Toribio Teodoro
(Courtesy of Philippine Shocking History)
(anu ba yung buhok ni Mr. Toribio?.. shocking ;p)
Sometimes we all need midnight walks. That is if we can't make it in day-time due to the tightness of our own schedules. Especially us men. To tell us what the day is about. Just to keep things under a clear perspective, bring it into focus.

I've learned that from my grandfather. Of course that's ahm.. the province were talkin about, at summer vacation when we were kids. He loved taking walks. Not to mention the time when people were what they really were, never any ill-intent even in the wee hours of the night. Unlike today when crimes proliferate.

It's all about that man's compelling shadow against the moon that's what they say, that masculine penumbra. A real man thinks.. ponders.. life is like chess moves. It's always touch move. But to the thinking man.. he always retrace back his steps.. the errors he's committed, because he knows there is no better way to move forward.  

Sometimes I don’t understand children. You ask them what piece they want to play and almost uniformly they choose the white piece. There’s a beauty in handling the black piece. All you need to do is defend and defend until you reach that point where your defense becomes an attack. Interesting right? The black piece has a built-in challenge, a challenge for you to rise above everything.  

People don’t realize the chess game is actually a battle of two kingdoms in a form of a siege. It’s the black that raises their draw bridge and it’s the white that draws their catapults. So what do you do when you are under siege? When your enemy is ready to cut your food and water supply? You have to act quickly while there’s enough storage, or your army will soon fail for lack of sustenance. But not too quick, remember you have the upper hand, you occupy a higher ground, you can see everything from where you stand, every slight movement on the ground. Your archers have the trajectory advantage. You act quick, but not too quick for in your quickness you have to wait. You wait for what? You wait for your opponent to commit a mistake. 

That’s the beauty of playing the black piece, it builds patience. And reality reveals in a hundred different chess moves, it is impossible not commit a single mistake. And so you rely on your opponent’s error. A mistake you patiently await even all throughout the game just in case your long learned well established strategies of old had proved to be lacking in order to out-wit him.  It all boils down to your manner of reading. If you don’t know how to read her mistakes as the white queen attacks, you’ll end up a defeated black king and a conquered kingdom.  

Honesty is not weakness. You can read better than that.  Or maybe learn back the basics. The basics of my grandfather, a virtuous honest man.

Well whatever it takes, I guess we just have to do our manly midnight walks in safety and with-in the bounds of our back or front yard for all I care. As long as we thinking men get our paths straightened and regain our focus. There is no better silent teacher than solitude. 

This is trademark infringement. Here's the case.. 

Respondent TORIBIO TEODORO, at first in partnership with JUAN KATINDIG and later as sole proprietor, has continuously used "ANG TIBAY," both as a trade-mark and as a trade-name, in the manufacture and sale of slippers, shoes, and indoor baseballs since 1910. 

He formally registered it as trade-mark and as trade-name. The growth of his business is a thrilling epic of Filipino industry and business capacity. Starting in an obscure shop in 1910 with a modest capital of P210 but with tireless industry and unlimited perseverance it grew into one of the early 100% Filipino owned firms. 

wow.. hats off to the Filipino ingenuity..

Petitioner ANA ANG registered the same trade-mark "Ang Tibay" for pants and shirts on 1932, and established a factory for the manufacture of said articles in the year 1937. 

Good thinking. Very apt you know?.. apelyido nya 'ANG', and just insert 'TIBAY' as kind of suffix and.. it says it all. The problem is may nauna ng nagregister before her.. and I don't think she's unaware of it.. the product was well known all over Philippine islands in those days... 

So parang sinabi nya lang kay Mr. Teodoro... "Ako ang talagang may karapatang gumamit ng 'ANG TIBAY' e ang pangalan ko 'Ang' eh 'Ang' ba pangalan mo? your last name starts with T pero 'Teodoro' naman di naman 'Tibay"  LOL (joke lang ah don't quote me on that)...

ANG was sued by TEODORO for trademark infringement. 

TRIAL COURT FAVORED ANG

The trial court absolved the defendant from the complaint, with costs against the plaintiff, on the grounds that 1. the two trademarks are dissimilar and are used on different and non-competing goods  2. that there had been no exclusive use of the trade-mark by the plaintiff; and 3. that there had been no fraud in the use of the said trade-mark by the defendant because the goods on which it is used are essentially different from those of the plaintiff. 

CA REVERSED

The Court of Appeals, however reversed that judgment, holding that BY UNINTERRUPTED AND EXCLUSIVE USE SINCE 1910 in the manufacture of slippers and shoes, RESPONDENT'S TRADE-MARK HAS ACQUIRED A SECONDARY MEANING; that the goods or articles on which the two trade-marks are used are similar or belong to the same class; and that the use by petitioner of said trade-mark constitutes a violation of sections 3 and 7 of Act No. 666. The defendant Director of Commerce did not appeal from the decision of the Court of Appeals.

ISSUE:  

Is the subsequent registration of existing trade name registrable due to its difference and non-competing products?

RULING:

The court said..

In the present state of development of the law on Trade-Marks, Unfair Competition, and Unfair Trading, THE TEST EMPLOYED BY THE COURTS TO DETERMINE WHETHER NONCOMPETING GOODS ARE OR ARE NOT OF THE SAME CLASS IS CONFUSION AS TO THE ORIGIN OF THE GOODS OF THE SECOND USER. 

Although two noncompeting articles may be classified under two different classes by the Patent Office because they are deemed not to possess the same descriptive properties, THEY WOULD, NEVERTHELESS, BE HELD BY THE COURTS TO BELONG TO THE SAME CLASS IF THE SIMULTANEOUS USE ON THEM OF IDENTICAL OR CLOSELY SIMILAR TRADE-MARKS WOULD BE LIKELY TO CAUSE CONFUSION AS TO THE ORIGIN, OR PERSONAL SOURCE, OF THE SECOND USER'S GOODS. 

They would be considered as NOT FALLING UNDER THE SAME CLASS ONLY IF THEY ARE SO DISSIMILAR OR SO FOREIGN TO EACH OTHER AS TO MAKE IT UNLIKELY THAT THE PURCHASER WOULD THINK THE FIRST USER MADE THE SECOND USER'S GOODS.

Such construction of the law is induced by cogent reasons of equity and fair dealing. The COURTS HAVE COME TO REALIZE THAT THERE CAN BE UNFAIR COMPETITION OR UNFAIR TRADING EVEN IF THE GOODS ARE NON-COMPETING, AND THAT SUCH UNFAIR TRADING CAN CAUSE INJURY OR DAMAGE TO THE FIRST USER OF A GIVEN TRADE-MARK, FIRST, BY PREVENTION OF THE NATURAL EXPANSION OF HIS BUSINESS AND, SECOND, BY HAVING HIS BUSINESS REPUTATION CONFUSED WITH AND PUT AT THE MERCY OF THE SECOND USER. 

The original owner is entitled to the preservation of the valuable link between him and the public that has been created by his ingenuity and the merit of his wares or services. Experience has demonstrated that WHEN A WELL-KNOWN TRADE-MARK IS ADOPTED BY ANOTHER EVEN FOR A TOTALLY DIFFERENT CLASS OF GOODS, IT IS DONE TO GET THE BENEFIT OF THE REPUTATION AND ADVERTISEMENTS OF THE ORIGINATOR OF SAID MARK, TO CONVEY TO THE PUBLIC A FALSE IMPRESSION OF SOME SUPPOSED CONNECTION BETWEEN THE MANUFACTURER OF THE ARTICLE SOLD UNDER THE ORIGINAL MARK AND THE NEW ARTICLES BEING TENDERED TO THE PUBLIC UNDER THE SAME OR SIMILAR MARK. 

In the case at bar, petitioner seems to make a frantic effort to retain the use of the mark "Ang Tibay." Her counsel suggests that instead of enjoining her from using it, she may be required to state in her labels affixed to her products the inscription: "NOT MANUFACTURED BY TORIBIO TEODORO."

Ahm.. "With your permission your honors we suggest to the honorable court that instead of enjoining petitioner from its use that she may be required for the least to affix distinguishing marks inscribed in her labels in fine prints the words  "NOT MANUFACTURED BY TORIBIO TEODORO." anu daw? whatdu fuck..

ehehe.. real funny.. imagine that label carrying your competitor's name plastered on all your products?... well If I'm Mr. Toribio I'd have no qualms with that I'd opt to tolerate it... negative publicity is still publicity... let's see the response of the court...

We think SUCH PRACTICE WOULD BE UNETHICAL AND UNWORTHY OF A REPUTABLE BUSINESSMAN. To the suggestion of petitioner, respondent may say, not without justice though with a tinge of bitterness: "Why offer a perpetual apology or explanation as to the origin of your products in order to use my trade-mark instead of creating one of your own?" On our part may we add, without meaning to be harsh, THAT A SELF-RESPECTING PERSON DOES NOT REMAIN IN THE SHELTER OF ANOTHER BUT BUILDS ONE OF HIS OWN.

The judgment of the Court of Appeals was affirmed.

Mr. Toribio Teodoro wins this case. 

Thursday, October 20, 2016

ETEPHA A.G. vs. DIRECTOR OF PATENTS and WESTMONT PHARMACEUTICALS INC.


"Stay with me"


8:15 p.m. I was on top of a building yesterday at the Ortigas area to have coffee and talk to a gorgeous woman. As I wait for her I walked over to the open lounge. I looked at the skies, and I've figured 'why there's not even a slightest trace of a storm coming?'. I could see the metropolis. The lights, the neons. And deep inside me I felt like violin strings in rhythmic patterns were playing some overture like that of a Batman movie. I felt the Dark Knight was standing there like a watchful guardian gazing at our own Gotham City.

Listen you know what? I spent my childhood living and grew up and played in one of the streets in Quezon City, particularly Guyabano St. in Project 2 Q.C. I could say that's one of the best times my life have ever had. My friends and I we played in the streets maybe not all but most of the Pinoy games. Tex, jolens, skateboards, bikes, go-karts, banggaan ng Tonka. We were the type where we're all well kept, sheltered and loved, yung tipong mga likod namen may mga white towel my goodness LOL, yung iba madalas hinahabol ng yaya, kaya pagmagusap kame we understand each other quickly, no proving, walang ere, wala masyadong away. And we loved it when we go out and play at night during summers especially during the 'ber' months where everything looks celebrative, happy and bright? ang sarap maglaro lalo pag Christmas na.. kase alam namen makakahawak na naman kame ng gun powder hehe (patago nga lang).

You know origami? we took out papers? and try learned the folds and make airplanes? So we took out crayons and colored and branded our planes. Mga dominant colors and logos ng superheroes, yung favorite namen. So ako pinapili una.. 'gusto ko si Batman'.. but the group agreed sakin daw dapat si Superman. E di kinuha ko.. since sya may pinakamalakas na powers. My best friend took Greenlantern which is really his favorite of all times, others took Flash, Spiderman... and then somebody took Batman... I told my self "Dang!".   I'd choose Batman over Superman anytime. I dunno for me since I was a kid and first owned my first Batman DC Comics (Although the first comics I've owned was Iron Fist) I've always admired him. Why? I dunno why. Maybe the mystique, the black suit. The mysteriousness of his being. Or maybe because he doesn't have powers, he's human, he feels, he's just like me. He's the outstretch of what the human mind and body can do.. even though the character was just a pigment of one's imagination. That fact that I could identify with him is more real.

Don't you know that Batman started as a detective when he was first written? He wasn't suppose to be a superhero. He was just suppose to be a super scientific hi-tech dude. And Bruce Wayne was an epitome not of a self-made man, he was just a billionaire playboy. The only difference is he's a philanthropist, if you google the word 'philanthropist' it means 'the love of humanity'.  A conventional modern definition is "private initiatives, for the public good, focusing on quality of life". So in a way it more than fits him. He got all the resources.

But you know? if I ever was the one who wrote Batman in DC Comics? I'd write him in a different manner. Maybe I'd keep the billionaire playboy type image, but I'd rewrite its romantic aspect. I would have him fall in love not in an ordinary conventional way. I'd give him a touch of etherealism.

You see if you look at the love interests of Batman (or Bruce Wayne), majority of them are socialites. Yes.. if you think it's only Rachel (Rachel Dawes), you're dead wrong. The real Batman had a string of love interests. Julie Madison was the first one. And she's royalty. Linda Page, another socialite. Of course there's the reporter Vicki Vale. Selina Kyle of course as we all know she's Catwoman. Who else.. Thalia al Ghul who's the daughter of one villain. Pamela Isley of course remember her? Ms. Poison Ivy? Natalia Knight, otherwise known as Nocturna, Julia Penyworth the daughter of Alfred (playboy talaga to eh). Sino pa ba.. si Wonder Woman of course. Although alam ko friends lang sila non.. pero when we were kids and nanunuod kame ng Superfriends (when you say Superfriends that means not on the Avenger side, means I'm talkin' about the Justice League side)  ang tanong ko lage "Bakit si Batman laging nakasakay sa invisible plane ni Wonderwoman? Sila ba?" (hihihi). There were times tatalon si Wonderwoman from the plane so si Batman magdadrive "Whuuuuuuuhhuhuu!!.. sabi na nga ba may something to eh" Who else.. well there's Black Canary na sinulot nya kay Green Arrow. Si Jillian Maxwell. who when he met at a party naging suspicioso si Alfred and therefore led him to check her background, turned out she's another villain. (geez halos lahat may criminal record haha, well not naman lahat). Charlotte Rivers.. but she's just another reporter of course. And many others. But these are not what I'm talking about. What I'm looking for is something like Lorna Shore.. the museum curator he met back then when they were kids. It was love at first sight as Bruce was able to find peace when he was with her for the first time since he was 8 years old after his parents got murdered. Kaya lang ang babaw ng storyline nilang dalawa. He left Lorna Shore co'z the Joker was getting suspicious who were the most important people in his life other than his dead parents, and he just doesn't want anything grave to happen to her. And so he took off to distract the Joker to gear the danger away from her. But that doesn't prove anything when you don't face everything together. I want someone that never left his side.  

I'm looking for something that has depth, something like more of a spirit he carries with him in his battles. Yung hindi lang playboy and met her at the course of his adventures. I want something that is intact. Like it's a contiguous part of him. There must be a base or something, a place not to just go back there to strengthen his weapons, but to nurse his wounds and to feel a peaceful beautiful loving presence. Yung tipong napakagandang babae with ethereal beauty na nakatira in an old Victorian mansion katabi lang ng batcave. That he falls deeply in love and he grew up with, and was sadly taken away from him by death and since then on she remained with him wherever he goes. Dang! that would be something. Yung may substance. Yung nandun sa puso mo at talagang walang makakacompete. And comes out to him in a dream or something and helps him in times of dire need.  Boy I'd rewrite him like that.

Anyway here's the case mga 'paƱero.

Respondent WESTMONT PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., a New York corporation, sought registration of trademark "ATUSSIN" a medicine used in the treatment of cough.  

Petitioner, ETEPHA, A. G., a corporation, objected. Petitioner claims  “ATUSSIN” is so CONFUSINGLY SIMILAR to its “PERTUSSIN” which is also used in treatment of coughs. And that the buying public will be misled into believing that Westmont's product is that of petitioner's which allegedly enjoys goodwill. (syempre nauna sila e)

So the Director of Patents is left with a choice..

May trademark ATUSSIN be registered, given the fact that PERTUSSIN, another trademark, which filed its objection had been previously registered in the Patent Office? — the DIRECTOR OF PATENTS ANSWERED AFFIRMATIVELY. 

Hence this appeal. Let's see if his decision will hold.

ISSUE: 

Was there a TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT?

RULING:

NONE.

Court said the objects of a trademark are :

1. "TO POINT OUT DISTINCTLY THE ORIGIN OR OWNERSHIP of the articles to which it is affixed
2. To secure to him who has been instrumental in bringing into market a superior article or merchandise the fruit of his industry and skill, and 
3.  To PREVENT FRAUD AND IMPOSITION."

1. NO COLORABLE IMITATION 

And the court stressed that we are to be guided by the rule that the validity of a cause for infringement is predicated upon COLORABLE IMITATION. The phrase "colorable imitation" denotes such a "CLOSE OR INGENIOUS IMITATION AS TO BE CALCULATED TO DECEIVE ORDINARY PERSONS, OR SUCH A RESEMBLANCE TO THE ORIGINAL AS TO DECEIVE AN ORDINARY PURCHASER, GIVING SUCH ATTENTION AS A PURCHASER USUALLY GIVES, AND TO CAUSE HIM TO PURCHASE THE ONE SUPPOSING IT TO BE THE OTHER."

2. IT'S COMMON PRACTICE

That the word "TUSSIN" figures as a component of both trademarks (Atussin & Pertussin) is nothing to wonder at. The Director of Patents aptly observes that it is "the common practice in the drug and pharmaceutical industries to 'fabricate' marks by using syllables or words suggestive of the ailments for which they are intended and adding thereto distinctive prefixes or suffixes". 

The "tussin" (in Pertussin and Atussin) was derived from the Latin root-word "tussis" meaning cough."Tussin" is MERELY DESCRIPTIVE; it is generic. It is accordingly barred from registration as trademark. 

E biro mo nga naman you register a generic word as your trademark e parang sinabe mo na na di nyo pede gamitin yung word na "love" kase ginamet ko na naparegister ko na. 

Iregister yon ng Director of Patents then it ends up as appellant having practically a monopoly of the word "tussin" in a trademark. Di ba?

Eto ang sabe ng korte... "While "tussin" by itself cannot thus be used exclusively to identify one's goods, it may properly become the subject of a trademark "by combination with another word or phrase". And this union of words is reflected in petitioner's Pertussin and respondent's Atussin, the first with prefix "Per" and the second with Prefix "A".

So there's no bone of contention right? 

3. VISUAL IMPRESSION

The court continued "The horizontal plain, block letters of Atussin and the diagonally and artistically upward writing of Pertussin leave distinct visual impressions. One look is enough to denude the mind of that illuminating similarity so essential for a trademark infringement case to prosper.

So yun naman pala eh.. horizontal yun lettering nung isa, yun isa naman diagonal upward.. sino pa ba magkakamali non? 

4. PHONETIC SIMILARITY

Eto pa sabe ng korte "As we take up Pertussin and Atussin once again, we cannot escape notice of the fact that the two words do not sound alike — when pronounced."

So it's clear there's no phonetic similarity between the two..

5. BY PRESCRIPTION

"Petitioner's and respondent's products are to be dispensed upon medical prescription.  The respective labels say so. An intending buyer must have to go first to a licensed doctor of medicine; he receives instructions as to what to purchase; he reads the doctor's prescription; he knows what he is to buy."

Yun ang akala nyo..

"We concede the possibility that buyers might be able to obtain Pertussin or Attusin without prescription. When this happens, then the buyer must be one thoroughly familiar with what he intends to get, else he would not have the temerity to ask for a medicine — specifically needed to cure a given ailment." 

Well at least the court conceded to the usual practice.. 

So the registration of Attusin was affirmed. Westmont wins this case. 

Sunday, October 16, 2016

DEL MONTE vs. CA


This is a case wherein the Supreme Court used the Holistic Test, but instead arrived at using the DOMINANCY TEST. (Lol)

Let's talk catsup. You know Del Monte? the famous catsup? I'm not sure about Jollibee, but this is the brand Mc Donald's uses in their burgers. I think Del Monte Foods Corporation is the carrier mother company having their main headquarters in Walnut Creek, California USA. So it's a 'state side' thingie so to speak right?, a catsup purely made out of hi-grade tomatoes.

Although we have our own Pinoy catsup here, (I dunno if Jollibee uses it.. I don't think so) the one that cater mostly to our own taste buds. UFC? Papa Catsup? Don't.. bash it. Because it's not made out of tomatoes, therefore there's no basis for taste comparisons okay? because it's made out of bananas actually. I like the taste of banana catsup on my chicken and eggs, but when it comes to burgers and beef, the taste of tomato catsup is so much better. Tomatoes are vegetables and bananas are fruits, so then of course it follows that UFC is therefore a fruit catsup. Which is more like the product of  Del Monte's adverse party here.

No not UFC. Although UFC PAPA Ketchup was also once involved in an infringement case where it sued Barrio Fiesta's PAPA Boy Lechon Sauce and won the case but that's a different story. That was catsup vs. lechon sauce (getting hungry here) where the mere issue was the use of the word "Papa". Whereas here in the case at bar it's tomato  vs. banana but the content of the product was immaterial. The issue here started from unrightful usage of bottle containers which ended up in CONFUSINGLY SIMILAR contentions, kase nakita nila halos pareho na, which we will discuss shortly. I know, now were really goin' bananas.. I hope you can still follow.

To give you a little bit of history you see banana ketchup was made when there was a shortage of tomato ketchup during World War II, due to lack of tomatoes and a comparatively high production of bananas. So.. Filipino ingenuity comes in right? lest we forget 'Necessity is the mother of all inventions'.

But that's then, now we comparatively have sufficient produce of tomatoes. So that explains us having a Del Monte local manufacturing unit here we call Del Monte Philippines although I'm not sure if this is the same Philippine Packing Corporation mentioned in this case. I think PHILPACK is the one who canned pineapples for Del Monte, as well as the bottling for their catsup I guess. Well it's up to you to do some clickings and find out for your selves.

Here's the case. So DEL MONTE as we have quite established, granted PHILIPPINE PACKING CORP. (PhilPack) the right to manufacture, distribute and sell in the Philippine various products under the Del Monte trademark and logo. Alright?

So Del Monte was able to acquire certificate of registration for its marks “Del Monte” and its logo; besides the Del Monte catsup bottle configuration.

Here comes the culprit..

Now years later, SUNSHINE SAUCE MANUFACTURING acquired certificate of registration for the logo of its SUNSHINE FRUIT CATSUP.

Here's the thing. Sunshine’s product is contained in various bottles, including Del Monte bottles. 

So.. dig that.

Having received reports that Sunshine was using its exclusively designed bottles and a logo confusingly similar to Del Monte’s,  PHILPACK warned Sunshine to desist from doing so.

SUNSHINE ignored, therefore PHILPACK and DEL MONTE sued. Okay?

Now.. The trial court ruled in favor of SUNSHINE.

(haha! I'm reminded of a good friend in school her name's Sunshine, LOL. Such a nice fine lady, always willing to assist and keep you in track with the lessons)

The Court of Appeals AFFIRMED the decision.  (Way to go Shine!! :) 

Hence, the petition for Certiorari under Rule 45.

ISSUE: 

Is the Sunshine label a COLORABLE IMITATION of the Del Monte trademark?

RULING: 

Court said YES.

The PREDOMINANT COLORS USED IN BOTH LABELS ARE THE SAME, green and red orange. 

The word “catsup” in both bottles is printed in white and the PRINT/LETTER STYLE IS THE SAME.

There you go..

Although the logo of Sunshine is not a tomato, BUT.. it approximates that of a tomato. 

(I wonder how it looks. 'Never thought there's such a way for a banana to make it look like a tomato.. possibilities are endless in art indeed)

Now listen to this.. the court had let us in to a usual practice..

Court said: The person who infringes a trademark DOES NOT NORMALLY COPY OUT BUT ONLY MAKES COLORABLE CHANGES, EMPLOYING ENOUGH POINTS OF SIMILARITY TO CONFUSE THE PUBLIC and enough points of differences to confuse the courts.

When a manufacturer prepares to package his product, HE HAS BEFORE HIM A BOUNDLESS CHOICE OF WORDS, PHRASES, COLOR AND SYMBOLS sufficient to distinguish his product from others. When SUNSHINE chose, without reasonable explanation, to use the same colors and letters as used by DEL MONTE, when the field of selection is so broad, the inevitable conclusion is that IT WAS DONE DELIBERATELY TO DECEIVE. 

Here's what gave it..

Furthermore, despite the many choices available to it, Sunshine OPTED TO USE DEL MONTE’S BOTTLE TO MARKET A PRODUCT which PhilPack also produces, notwithstanding the caution “DEL MONTE CORPORATION, NOT TO BE REFILLED.” 

This shows Sunshine’s BAD FAITH and its intention to CAPITALIZE ON THE REPUTATION of Del Monte, and pass off its product as that of the latter.

So in effect the SC reversed both decisions of the lower courts and Del Monte won this case.

Thursday, October 13, 2016

ASIA BREWERY vs. CA


They say there’s scientific findings that there’s heightened activity in a woman’s brain when a guy displays humor and makes funny jokes, which the possibility of she falling in love with him is not far from happening. Yes that may be true but I partly disagree. I think DRAMA and not COMEDY is still the shortest and the deepest way to win a woman’s heart.

I've tested it my self. Not that I'm such a bad humorist. On the contrary in fact I think I could pass as a good comedian my self granted I'm in the mood and everybody sets the mood for it.

I'm not the slapstick type. Although I enjoyed slapstick comedy as early as high school since I've had sidekicks (I dunno why) even up to college who laughed at my jokes like hyenas (you know like ahihihihihihi!) . Actually to tell you frankly I really couldn't categorically say that I could pass as a good comedian. It's not in my blood I'm the semi-serious type. It's probably my gullible buddies that made a trend for it kase sinasalo nila mga punchline ko. Co'z generally when I throw a joke in class in absence of the teacher during high school where our pass time was to tease the girls, and where the girls big challenges were 'barahin yung mga boys', di talaga slapstick. 

I'm more of the swabe type. One punchline lang and my gullible sidekicks would laugh crazy like hyenas. One teacher was even amazed I was just seated in a comfortable armed chair naka de-ocho touching my chin with a half-devious smile and I threw a joke and my classmates were laughing like crazy on the floor.  But that's usually a private joke among our selves. I cannot do stand-up comedy. Kaya di ko masabe kung magaling ako mag joke talaga kase nasanay ako ng may mga gullible friends na sumasalo sa punchline ko. Probably because of friendship I guess.

So is COMEDY really the way to win a woman’s heart? I wouldn't say that. Asar na asar pa nga mga babae samen non eh. But some girls really couldn't help it. They laugh. Oh but the irony is, yung maganda sa klase? ayaw ako pagjokin.  Panget daw sa kanya tawa ng tawa na lalake. Gusto nya medyo seryoso. Aw!! So I could use that as a premise right? Yung magaganda are the ones usually more prone to drama.

I'm not talking about drama perse the way Pinoy teleserye sees it. Sigawan mode "WALANG HIYAA KAAA!!!!" blah blah etc. I'm talking Intelligent Conversations. Exemplary Actuation. Decisive Actions. Intimate Communications. The universal theme.  Actually the root word from the Greek word 'Drama' doesn't mean crying, in tears, or melancholia. The word is never even equated to tragedy. The root word means "action".  Just 'action'. So it's really far from the iyakan type. Maybe drama just means 'excellence of actions'. And we've just misunderstood it all our lives.

Anyway, I think we must remember that love is an activity that comes from the heart.  If comedy struck something in the woman’s brain, then that’s just taking the long way to win her heart when scientifically we all know that the shortest distance between two points is a straight line. So why not go straight to her heart instead? Therefore drama is more effective to win her for it strikes the very core of the inner chambers of her heart. And that’s bulls eye if you know what I'm talking about.

For me I think the best is when you know how to balance the two but you don't get stereotyped to either of the two. Maybe I guess really it's all a matter of balancing the two ancient Greek muses Thalia and Melpomene so to speak. But if you'd ask me? to choose between the two?  Even though I love laughing? I'd gear more on the drama side. Because it makes me not forget reality. I dunno just thinking. 

Here's the case.

Remember the Beer Wars? I think this happened in the 90s? This is the case for that. Listen closely.

In 1988, San Miguel Corporation filed a complaint against Asia Brewery Inc. for   INFRINGEMENT OF TRADEMARK and UNFAIR COMPETITION through CONFUSING SIMILARITY on account of Asia Brewery's Beer Pale Pilsen which they call Beer Na Beer. (Well I think there's nothin' wrong with that, the company decided to compete, this is a free world)  So this is the product which has been competing with the former’s San Miguel Pale Pilsen for a share of the local beer market.  So it's San Miguel Pale Pilsen vs. Beer Na Beer. 

I couldn't really distinguish when it comes to taste and I'm probably not a good judge for it since bata pa ako nung nagaaway sila eh, bawal pa ako humawak ng bote, and I think Beer na Beer now is already defunct..

So the case was filed right? And the trial court ruled in favor of Asia Brewery. The appellate court, however, overturned the trial court’s ruling deciding therefore in favor of San Miguel Corp. 

So naturally through Rule 45 of the Rules of Court Asia Brewery appealed by Certiorari.

ISSUE:

Is Asia Brewery guilty of unfair competition, arising from the allegedly “confusing similarity” in the general appearance of ABI’s Beer Pale Pilsen against SMC’s San Miguel Pale Pilsen?

RULING:

The answer is No.

1. Court said the dominant feature of SMC’s trademark is “San Miguel Pale Pilsen” while ABI’s is “Beer Pale Pilsen”. The word “Beer” does not appear in SMC’s product, nor the words “San Miguel” appear in ABI’s product. 

2.  Neither the sound, spelling or appearance can Beer Pale Pilsen be said to be confusingly similar to San Miguel Pale Pilsen. 

3.  San Miguel does not have exclusive rights to the generic or descriptive words “pale” and “pilsen”. Neither does it have the exclusive right to use 320 ml. steinie bottle with white rectangular label.

Ouch..

Court said the amber color is a functional feature of the beer bottle as the color prevents the transmission of light and provides the maximum protection to beer. 

So there's scientific basis to it... Ganda nun ah..

The bottle capacity is the standard prescribed by the Metric System Board of the Department of Trade. 

The white label is the most economical to use and presents the strongest contrast to the bottle. San Miguel cannot claim monopoly to such features as the protection provided by law is confined to non-functional features. 

4.  Further, Beer Pale Pilsen is not being passed off as San Miguel Beer Pale Pilsen. 

Onga naman.. nakakita na ako ng bote nun eh..

It does not result to confusion inasmuch as beer is ordered by brand, and is not taken freely from supermarket shelves. 

The points of dissimilarity of the products outnumber their points of similarity. 

The appellate court is correct in its finding that Asia Brewery does not infringe upon SMC’s trademark nor does it commit unfair competition. 

I Think the court like the McDonald's case again used the DOMINANCY TEST here instead of the HOLISTIC TEST.

So assailed CA decision was affirmed and Asia Brewery wins this case.

Question: Asan na ngayon yung Beer na Beer Pale Pilsen? Gusto ko matikman.  

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

MCDONALD'S CORPORATION vs. L.C. BIG MAK BURGER, INC.


Back in the 90s you know I've learned power chords actually from a girl. Dig that she's so cool. Co'z actually I was more succumbed to guitar licks and rock leads I didn't know power chords were that amazing.

So  I brought my electric guitar to their house and had one to one session with her. Barbie Almalbis' 'Dahilan' was our first practice piece.

"Kunin mo lang lage yun dalawang heavy strings. Index finger mo dito.. ring finger mo dito.. ganun lang ang porma, tapos move move mo lang follow mo yung chord progression and let it slide" "Ganyan?" "O yan.. tira"... "Ang sarap pala ng power chords grabe" "Sabe sayo eh". 

She took a break, went inside. And after 5 minutes I figured it was taking her so long, so I went in.. found her at the dining table.. nagtitimpla ng Milo. "Nu 'gawa mo?"  "Nagtitimpla ng Milo.. 'tu mo? timpla kita" "Titimpla?" "Helloo?" (she took a drink) "Ang Milo kinakaen yan di yan iniinom... sinasayang mo lang eh!". And she bursted laughing while drinking.. lumabas yung Milo sa ilong hahahaha!. Damn it I was laughing like an hyena on my way out.

Alright. Here's the case.

MCDONALD'S CORPORATION, Petitioner here of course as we all know is a US corporation that operates a global chain of fast-food restaurants. 

Gosh.. If you don't know Ronald McDonald you'd probably take out a stun gun and freeze him or get a club and wack him on the head if he suddenly comes out from the bushes.  

McDonald's owns the "Big Mac"? their trademark for its "double-decker hamburger sandwich." It's actually registered with the US Trademark Registry since 1979. 

So based on this Home Registration, McDonald's applied for the registration of the same mark in the Principal Register of the then PHILIPPINE BUREAU OF PATENTS, TRADEMARKS AND TECHNOLOGY ("PBPTT") (that's now IPO, Intellectual Property Office). Which was approved of course.

Now here comes the Pinoy ingenuity..

Respondent L.C. BIG MAK BURGER, INC. (LOL) a domestic corporation which operates fast-food outlets and snack vans in Metro Manila and nearby provinces comes out with a menu. Respondent corporation's menu includes hamburger sandwiches and other food items. (natatawa na ako)

Snack van pala ah.. naalala ko yung mga Jollijeep sa Makati... minsan kumakaen ako dun when I used to work at Ayala. Sarap kase kumaen ng nakatayo, presko, and nagdadaldalan kayo habang kumakaen, ang lalakas pa ng tawa nyo kahet nka corporate attire kayo.

So eto na nga si Big Mak..

On  October 1988, respondent corporation L.C. Big Mak Inc. applied with the PBPTT for the registration of the "Big Mak"  mark for its hamburger sandwiches. 

Pasok si Juan de la Cruz.. "ah 'Big Mac ah'??.. meron din kami nyan 'Big Mak' "  ahahaha..

And.. well of course the registration was opposed by Mr. Ronald McDonald's. McDonald's also informed LC Big Mak chairman of its exclusive right to the "Big Mac" mark and requested him to desist from using the "Big Mac" mark or any similar mark.

Pinoy talaga patawa no? "Register naten, register naten dali". 

Having received no reply, petitioners sued L.C. Big Mak Burger, Inc. and its directors before Makati RTC   for TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT and UNFAIR COMPETITION. 

So.. 'Big Mac' sued 'Big Mak'..

RTC rendered  Decision finding respondent corporation LIABLE FOR TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT and UNFAIR COMPETITION. 

Here's the thing...

CA reversed the RTC ruling.

ISSUE:  

Is respondent corporation liable for TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT? 

RULING:    

Yes.

Section 22 of Republic Act No. 166, as amended, defines trademark infringement as follows: 
Infringement, what constitutes. - Any person who 
1. shall use, without the consent of the registrant, any reproduction, counterfeit, copy or colorable imitation of any registered mark or trade-name in connection with the sale, offering for sale, or advertising of any goods, business or services on or in connection with which such use is likely to cause confusion or mistake or to deceive purchasers or others as to the source or origin of such goods or services, or identity of such business; or  
2. reproduce, counterfeit, copy, or colorably imitate any such mark or trade-name and apply such reproduction, counterfeit, copy, or colorable imitation to labels, signs, prints, packages, wrappers, receptacles or advertisements intended to be used upon or in connection with such goods, business or services, shall be liable to a civil action by the registrant for any or all of the remedies herein provided.
To establish trademark infringement, the following elements must be shown: 

(1) the validity of plaintiff's mark; 
(2) the plaintiff's ownership of the mark; and 
(3) the use of the mark or its colorable imitation by the alleged infringer results in "likelihood of confusion." 

Court said it is the element of likelihood of confusion that is the gravamen of trademark infringement.

1st element:  
A mark is valid if it is distinctive and not merely generic and descriptive. 

The "Big Mac" mark, which should be treated in its entirety and not dissected word for word, is neither generic nor descriptive. Generic marks are commonly used as the name or description of a kind of goods, such as "Lite" for beer. Descriptive marks, on the other hand, convey the characteristics, functions, qualities or ingredients of a product to one who has never seen it or does not know it exists, such as "Arthriticare" for arthritis medication. On the contrary, "Big Mac" falls under the class of fanciful or arbitrary marks as it bears no logical relation to the actual characteristics of the product it represents. As such, it is highly distinctive and thus valid. 

2nd element:  
Petitioners have duly established McDonald's exclusive ownership of the "Big Mac" mark. Prior valid registrants of the said mark had already assigned his rights to McDonald's. 

So the court finds that there is confusion of goods in this case since RESPONDENTS USED THE "BIG MAK" MARK ON THE SAME GOODS, I.E. HAMBURGER SANDWICHES, THAT PETITIONERS' "BIG MAC" MARK IS USED.

Ayoown..

There is also confusion of business due to Respondents' use of the "Big Mak" mark in the sale of hamburgers, the same business that petitioners are engaged in, also results in confusion of business. The registered trademark owner may use his mark on the same or similar products, in different segments of the market, and at different price levels depending on variations of the products for specific segments of the market. The registered trademark owner enjoys protection in product and market areas that are the normal potential expansion of his business. 

Here's the Dominancy Test Theory.. 

Furthermore, IN DETERMINING LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION, THE SC HAS RELIED ON THE DOMINANCY TEST (the similarity of the prevalent features of the competing trademarks that might cause confusion) over the so called HOLISTIC TEST (the consideration of the entirety of the marks as applied to the products, including the labels and packaging).

Applying the dominancy test, Respondents' use of the "Big Mak" mark results in likelihood of confusion. Aurally the two marks are the same, with the first word of both marks phonetically the same, and the second word of both marks also phonetically the same. Visually, the two marks have both two words and six letters, with the first word of both marks having the same letters and the second word having the same first two letters. 

So of course Mr. Ronald McDonald wins this case.

Tuesday, April 28, 2015

IPL BAR REVIEWER: Final Requirement


INTRODUCTION:  Ever read of the story of how a student once wrote his bar reviewer questions as submitted requirement for his IPL Class?  In one of his questions he wrote something like how Pedro tried to put up a carinderia business in front of his house and decided to call it COOKING NG INA MO, and how his neighbor Juan living across the street kinda felt somethin’ different everytime he wakes up in the morning and sees it so he decided to compete with Pedro’s business and put up his own and called it COOKING NG INA MO RIN.  Question, was there trademark infringement?  (Lol) Well guess what? Were not gonna delve into that. I’ve written my own as requirement for my own IPL back subject class (darn). Here are 10 scenarios I've written to address 10 legal situations in Intellectual Property Law. Don't worry, I’ve decided to write something decent.

 1.  
Q.    Horse and Hound Philippines, a locally licensed British publication that publishes articles on horse sports like Equestrianism, Polo, Steeplechase Races as well as article features on hunting sports like famous breeds of hunting dogs published a submitted article by a young dog lover named Remington Policarpio an 8th grade student of the Philippine Science High School on an annual canine competition held in London. His article entitled  “UNDERDOGS TAKES THE LEAD: The Blood Hounds Takes Unexpected Front Row as the Best Hunting Dog this Year flanking the Retrievers”  was chosen as one of the best articles that will carry their May issue.  Having no knowledge and not being aware of his rights on copyright ownership, Remington read a first copy of  the issue with his published work and his name on it and was elated and felt already compensated by the magazine’s effort  of publishing his article. Eventually getting good reviews on the article and the magazine itself, the publication decided to republish Remington’s article on its next quarter British issue and on its local Christmas issue.  Is Remington’s rights  being violated?

A.   Yes.  The submission of a literary work to a newspaper, magazine or periodical for publication shall constitute only a license to make a single publication. Unless a greater right is expressly granted.  In this case there was absence of an expressly granted greater right to republish said article signed between Remington and the Magazine. Moreover,  Remington being a high school student unaware of his rights getting elated by the mere site of the attributions on his name shouldn’t have been took advantage of and exploited and instead should have been oriented and informed by the publication itself of the boy’s rights.    


2.  
Q.     Neil a top student of quantum physics designed a computer program called DOTA (Detailing Oversized Tractors thru Automation). The program was a concept software aimed at redesigning construction equipments for the top 5 local construction companies. In other words, he was commissioned by a consortium to try to reinvent the wheel in furtherance of steel science.  He managed to come up with a prototype of  what he called CraneDozer,  a combination of a crane and a bulldozer built as one.  The consortium thought it was a marvelous idea, and so they took the prototype work and the code and the blueprint and immediately called for a press release. In the press conference the companies CEOs were interviewed as saying that the equipment shall be produced as soon as possible. In the same interview they were asked if they would publish a formula book for furtherance of steel and construction science. They said yes, they would publish a book attributed to the 5 companies dedicated for furtherance of the steel industry.  Neil saw everything on TV and quickly hired his lawyer friend. If you are the lawyer and Neil’s friend what would you do?

A.    I will file a case for infringement of copyright.  Obviously there is absence of an employer-employee relationship between my client and the consortium. In such case, a work commissioned by a person other than an employer  who pays for it and work is made in pursuance of the commission, the person who commissioned the work shall have ownership of work, but the copyright thereto pursuant to Chapter VI  of the Law on Copyright of the Intellectual Property Code shall remain with the creator. Unless there is a written stipulation to the contrary. Well assuming as you see that my client is highly intelligent and wouldn’t have called for my service had there no need, then it is highly probable there is absence of such stipulation.
  

3.
Q.  Raven and Janella co-authored a book on Physical Education entitled “How to Win A Triathlon Competition Through Core Exercises”  Since Raven is a Fitness First competent trainer /coach he had come up with a complete series of core exercises for the book. And since Janella is a publicist she merely shared her inputs on well balanced diet and nutrition she had learned from the internet and took care of the publishing work herself.   The book was published and both were earning royalties 50/50 as co-authors.  Raven eventually pursued full ownership of the work saying he conceptualized and wrote around 90% of the literary work.  Is Raven’s contention correct?  To whom really does the copyright ownership belong?

A.  In the case of work of joint authorship, the co-authors shall be the original owners of the copyright and in the absence of agreement, their rights shall be governed by the rules on co-ownership. If, however, the book consists of parts that can be used separately and the author of each part can be identified, the author of each part shall be the original owner of the copyright in the part that he has created.


4.
Q.    Devin Restituto a sophomore college student and a school organ staff member , writer and contributor wrote a translation/adaptation of a famous poem and literary work by a Filipino author Jose Garcia Villa. He was always usually heard opining in class by his English teachers that Jose Garcia Villa is his favorite author. He was even found using Doveglion as his pen-name, codename or even callsign when playing DOTA with his friends. In his submitted article he almost copy-pasted the whole original copyrighted Jose Garcia Villa article and interposed his own translations between each paragraphs. He was confronted by the school paper editor telling him that it was a copyrighted work and that he’s certainly treading on certain legal grounds.   What do you think?

A.   Devin’s kind of work maybe unoriginal perse if we base our perspective plainly on the original author’s rights, but on the contrary little do we know that inevitably there is another right being created where the new work can be considered diminishingly original as a whole. His work falls under what we call Derivative Work. Derivative works are alterations of original literary and artistic works. His inputs on his translations together with the original work are considered original intellectual creations deserving of a separate and independent copyright protection.


5.  
Q.   Anne Guevarra  is a veteran journalist and TV reporter.  Her latest assignment was to work closely and extract information on a weekly basis with the Bureau of Fisheries its programs for the local fisherfolks of  Candijay, Bohol.  The reason why Anne took the assignment is that it was special for her. She took up Marine Biology in college and because of  scarcity of jobs in her field of work during her graduation she opted trying out for audition as TV reporter  in one of the local networks of which she passed instantly.  Now she couldn’t believe she is faced with the two things she both love.  In one of  her private interviews with the Director of the bureau, she asked for a copy of all the species of  all kinds of fish found in and endemic in our Philippine waters. Thinking he was giving public information a favor, the Director gladly obliged handing her a folder of said data complete with corresponding pictures.  As soon as Anne reached Manila ports she compiled all the data, came up with a manuscript and talked with National Bookstore for publication in her name.  Did Anne violate any copyright laws?   Was the right of the Bureau of Fisheries infringed?        
      
A.   Yes and No.  Our copyright law states that ‘No copyright shall subsist in any work of the Government of the Philippines “  Therefore what Anne took from the Bureau of the Fisheries is a non-copyrighted article meaning no copyright exist  and so no copyright therefore is infringed.  Instead what she secured is government  property of which it was handed to her by her asking in the tenor that it is an information made available and ready any time the public needs it.  Her non-disclosure however of her intention to publicize in a book under her name and exploitation of the government work given to her for profit may be subject to injunction. Unless such agency or office among other things such as giving proper attributions eventually be informed after the publication as to impose the condition of payment of royalties.  


 6.  
Q.    Odette is a ballerina. She is a associated with a 10 member  guild of a young exemplary professional ballerinas called Prima Rosa.  Together  the guild  came up with a concept of a new ballet production called “The Sleep of Endymia”  where in they conceptualized the story and new ballet movements of their own each one contributing to the repertoire.  Odette was seldom present in the conceptualization and therefore contributed a minimal portion. Yet she however  atleast  handed her inputs though written suggestions.    Soon the production took its stage and the performance and applause were superb.  Comes the throwing of flowers and acknowledgements  and at Odette’s surprise her name was mentioned merely as a performer and not as co-author of the production.  At the backstage she confronted the chairperson of the guild questioning why she wasn’t given proper attributions. The chairperson explained her contributions were minimal and the fact that she wasn’t always around when her opinion is needed sent an impression to the whole guild that she wasn’t interested to be part of the contributors.  Odette defended that she is a part of the group, and therefore she has every moral right to be mentioned as part of its group work.  Is Odette’s contention valid?
               
A.    No. When an author contributes to a collective work, his or her moral right to have his contributions attributed to him or her is deemed waived unless he expressly reserves it.  The group must have taken her chronic absence and minimal contributions as disinterest to the accolades and attributions and so the impressions they took is that all she merely wanted was to be part of the physical production.


7.  
Q.    Prof. Straider Valdez is an English Composition and Literature instructor teaching in one of the exclusive schools in Manila. In most of his lectures he uses the quotes, poetry and literary works of famous local and foreign authors and writers and in one particular series of lecture he uses the works of his favorite author Ernest Hemingway extensively. In fact he published a compilation of his works  as  lecture workbooks entitled “Work Book on the Composition and Brevity of the Works of Famous Authors –by  Straider E. Valdez”  and sold them to his class for a minimal fee.  The School Ethics Department had found out about his style of educating his students and was called for to validate his stand.  In the meeting he was asked whether he realizes that he was already infringing on copyright laws of such authors.  He explained carefully that what he is doing is but fair and practical. And that he in no way was infringing on any subsisting copyrights of any literary works whether local or foreign since he was merely operating on the world wide principle of Fair Use.  Is the professor’s contention tenable?

A.    Yes. As stated in Sec. 185 of the Copyright Law, the fair use of a copyrighted work, criticism, news reporting, teaching including multiple copies for classroom use, scholarship, research and similar purposes is not an infringement of copyright. Moreover, he gave attributions as to the source and the name of the authors as what is expected of an individual availing of such fair use.


8.  
Q.     Angel is an accomplished lecturer in the field of Human Behavior and in one of her dissertation on “The Rationale On The 16 Alarming Behaviors On Social Media”  incepting her findings on a Freudan principle, she planned on having her work publicly disseminated and published and eventually copyrighted and she was surprised her work became best seller.  She registered her work with the National Library  yet had not either personally or by registered mail delivered 2 complete copies as copyright requirement,  yet paid the prescribed fee for the certificate of deposit. The reason for the delay are the numerous lectures she is obliged to conduct.  Three weeks have passed since she received a demand letter from the copyright office as notice of deposit of her works, but she however changed her mind thinking the copyright might be too early since she is still in a continued process of developing  the concept thinking there could be more findings should she wait a little longer as she continue formulating her lectures.  She had registered, paid the fee and yet had not deposited her work. Did she loose her copyright process?   

A.     No. The copyright owner shall be merely liable to pay a fine equivalent to the required fee per month of delay and to pay the National Library and the Supreme Court Library the amount of the retail price of the best edition of the work.


9.
Q. Patrick’s Cologne Inc. came to the Philippines in 1973. During the 1980s, they had huge marketing campaign so they became known in the Philippines. Pat-Rick’s Cologne Inc.  was a large well known  perfumery product  in the provinces. In 1980, Patrick’s Cologne Inc.  filed a trademark infringement case. It was proven that some people actually think Pat-Rick’s Cologne is affiliated with Patrick’s Cologne Inc.  and was creating confusion. Decide on the case.

A. Pat-Rick’s Cologne Inc.  Trademark protects goodwill. Patrick’s Cologne’s goodwill was established in 1980. Pat-Rick’s Cologne was already established in Philippines even before Patrick’s Cologne became known because of its marketing campaign.


10.  
Q.     Anthony was an excellent professional blog writer. His blog existed since 2001 and he even availed himself of a domain name for it. Yet he never uses his real name but he uses the pseudonym Bluerose in all his writings. In September of 2003 he fell in love. She wooed a very lovely elegant girl named Serene.  He would drive his car next to her parked car leaving a blue rose on her windshield and disappearing  leaving the girl romantically thrilled yet  full of questions every time she reaches her car after class. In one occasion he left a note where only a blog address and his codename were mysteriously written. She found the blog and fell in-love with the author’s mysterious name and his brilliant mind.  Eventually they met and felt even more in-love. They got married and had kids. They built a happy home.  2015, Anthony died of an accident leaving his wife and two kids.  In a sheer effort to recall and relive their first meeting Serene kept coming back to Anthony’s blog. Couldn’t help but smiling and all teary eyed she went through all his posts from the very beginning and read it carefully. She got an idea, she thought of publishing all his writings from 2001 up to 2015 in one book entitled “Quiet Thoughts of The Bluerose”  She contacted Anvil to do it for her and Anvil knowing her unique love story and the excellent  worth of her husband’s writing saw something worth publishing. Only there’s one catch. She remembered Anthony saying before he died that if  ever he would  publish a book, the world will never see a trace of his real name but  only his penname Bluerose. Serene undeniably showing a mutual love for the name since her college windshield days gave in to her husband’s wish. The book was published without Anthony’s real name. Since there are no authors as tangible as a real given name, who would represent the author Bluerose on feature write-ups and public dissemination and accolades and receiving royalties?  If Serene decides to disclose Anthony’s identity, what do you think will happen? What are the posthumous rights of Anthony?     
   
(Dang! I could be a fu-kin’ romantic novelist I swear)  
     
A.     Pursuant to Sec. 179 of the Copyright Law of the Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines, the publishers shall be deemed to represent the authors of articles and other writings published without the names of the authors or under pseudonym.   There is however an exception stating that unless the contrary appears, or the pseudonyms or adopted name leaves no doubt as to the author’s identity. That exception however is not applicable in this case, since Anthony’s real name had never even been public in character. He was never a celebrity nor have published any book using his real name, nor have been known publicly as the writer of the Bluerose blog. He has kept his name secret behind his own pseudonym for years where only his wife and their close friends knew about.

Should Serene decides to disclose Anthony’s identity then, the publisher Anvil shall step back or take a back seat in representing the author’s work  yet still support in favor of the author’s wife. 

In posthumous terms whether economic  or moral rights, the heirs of the author has all rights, economically to receive royalties from reproduction and public distribution, and morally to receive accolades and attributions for the author’s works from the very day of the copyright through the author’s lifetime  and 50 years after his death. The person or persons to be charged with the posthumous enforcement of these moral rights of attributions and accolades shall be named in writing to be filed with the National Library. In default of such person or persons, such enforcement shall devolve upon either the author’s heir’s and in default of the heirs, the Director of the National Library. 

In view of this case, the wife of the posthumous author Serene shall take charge.